Educator Evaluation Beacon

  • Home
  • District Determined Measures
  • Student Surveys
  • Contact Us
  • Educator Evaluation at CES

Baseball Informs Educator Evaluation

March 31, 2014 by Damon Douglas

baseballOn Red Sox Opening Day, we look to baseball for guidance. In calling balls and strikes, umpires address calibration challenges similar to those facing school principals charged with evaluating teachers. To gain greater inter-rater reliability, umpires’ performances are compared to camera-based compu-scores, while school evaluators collaboratively score video clips of teachers in action.

This New York Times article analyzes patterns in umpires’ strike- and ball-calling errors: “Baseball insiders have long suspected what our research confirms: that umpires tend to make errors in ways that favor players who have established themselves at the top of the game’s status hierarchy. But our findings are also suggestive of the way that people in any sort of evaluative role — not just umpires — are unconsciously biased by simple “status characteristics.” Even constant monitoring and incentives can fail to train such biases out of us.”

If we apply this theory to teacher evaluation, are school evaluators more likely to give favorable ratings to teachers with greater status in the building?

Filed Under: Evaluation

Like what you're reading? Share it.

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Print
  • More
  • Tumblr
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Pocket

Welcome to the Educator Evaluation Blog

Learning to use the Educator Evaluation System is a journey. We can help ease your travels by providing answers to your questions, alerts about changes, and tips about how to navigate the process.

Subscribe by Email


Categories

  • Counselors (1)
  • Evaluation (71)
    • District Determined Measures (37)
    • Staff feedback (5)
    • Student Surveys (9)
    • teacher rubric (2)
  • Events (4)
  • Examples (8)
  • Health (1)
  • History (1)
  • Physical Education (1)
  • School nurses (2)
  • Science (1)
  • SISP (2)
  • Social Studies (1)
  • Student feedback (1)

Archives

Copyright 2023 Collaborative for Educational Services · All Rights Reserved